Kerry muhlestein, egyptian papyri and the book of abraham. Rhodes 2003 fair conference what we are going to be talking about is a response to the recent video, the lost book of abraham. Why does mormon church continue to include the book of abraham in their canonized scripture. Why does mormon church continue to include the book of. Explores the joseph smith papyrus and demonstrates that joseph smiths claim that he had translated the book of abraham from it was a fabrication. Sep 30, 2016 william clayton made the book of breathings directly relevant to the kinderhook plates, in his journal entry, by claiming the kinderhook plates were on the breast of a skeleton. Christopher woods associate professor of sumerology discusses the likelihood that the practice of egyptian religion took place in ur of chaldea c. The book of mormon if the book of abraham was a fraud. The institute for religious research has published two major resources challenging the authenticity of the book of abraham. How the book of abraham exposes the false nature of mormonism. Translation of the hor book of breathings by michael d. Upon examination by professional mormo n an d non morm on egyptologists, these fragments were identified as egyptian funerary texts, including t he breath ing permit of hor and the book of the dead, among others. Rhodes published his ninetysevenpage book, the hor book of breathings.
Without any supportive historical data, the author of the ces letter assumes that joseph was aware of the first book of napoleon and constructed the book of mormon by using structural elements from it. The book of breathings papyrus has no writing in red ink and is in an extremely poor state of preservation. An illustrated version of the article is ritner, the breathing permit of hor among the joseph smith papyri, journal of near eastern studies 62 july 2003. I would also love to hear some reasoned arguments about your views on the book of abraham and why no other translations match that of js. Full text of book of breathings article by lanny bell see other formats egypt and beyond essays presented to leonard h. Why doesnt the translation of the egyptian papyri found. Deification in the book of breathings and the revelation of st. Rhodes also provides information about the dating of the hor book of breathing, citing coenen that this is the earliest reliably dated book of breathings made by isis. Topics lds, mormon, book of abraham, heiroglyphics, rhodes. Aug 21, 20 what is the book of breathings and book of the dead.
Though the original characters in hieratic are missing from the joseph smith hor book of breathings, there academic restoration is secure in the fact that these appear in line 98 of the more complete book of breathings, which isis made for her brother spouse osiris papyrus louvre n. Please, i would love to hear some reasoned arguments as to why it is true. Eldon tanner, sent out for the translation, expecting it to prove smiths true translation abilities. Abraham refers to a picture in the text of the book of abraham abr. Mormon and nonmormon egyptologists agree that the characters on the fragments do not match the translation given in the book of abraham. Deification in the book of breathings and the revelation. Book of mormon, doctrine and covenants, pearl of great. Disproves mormonism using the bible, mormon scripture, statistical analysis and common sense. You are coming up with too many reasons why the book of mormon is fake instead of why it is true. Items do not represent the official views of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints or of book of mormon central. Gees presentation creates a huge problem with mormonism and apologetics. Upon their publication in 1967, the joseph smith papyri nos. From a believers perspective, however, there are several possible theories to account for this. William clayton made the book of breathings directly relevant to the kinderhook plates, in his journal entry, by claiming the kinderhook plates were on the breast of a skeleton.
The text was revealed much in the same manner as that of the book of mormon, without the need for the actual papyri, 2 the text was present on portions of the papyri that are missing, and 3 the book of abraham manuscript was attached to the book of breathings manuscript and was. The books of breathing are several late ancient egyptian funerary texts, intended to enable deceased people to continue to exist in the afterlife. However, in 1966 several fragments of the papyri were found in the archives of the metropolitan museum of art in new york and in the lds church archives. Rhodes at the 2003 conference of fair the foundation for apologetic information and research, a pro mormon apologetics organization. One such response was a lecture by mormon egyptologist michael d. Dec 23, 2015 for the book of breathings is before all else, as bonnet observes, a composite, made up of compilations and excerpts from older funerary sources and mortuary formulasof particular interest to us is the close association of the book of breathings with the facsimiles of the book of abraham. The vignette is one and the sameand its been a delight to visit the church history library of late, where the vignette is on display. While translating the book of mormon, he used the urim and thummim rather than. How the book of abraham exposes the false nature of. Oct 18, 2016 the joseph smith book of breathings opens with a vignette representing osiris on a lioncouch. Why doesnt the translation of the egyptian papyri found in 1967. Scriptural studies egyptology and the book of abraham. The breathing permit of hor or hor book of breathing is a ptolemaic era funerary text written for.
The document of breathings made by isis is not the book of abraham, and most latterday saints have never claimed it was, he said. The first book of napoleon was singled out as being more similar than other books, but an assessment of genuine similarities and their possible importance was not sought or provided. These groups were led by prophets who recorded their religious and secular histories on metal plates. I understand why mormon apologists want to move on from this embarrassingly impossible to win argumentand of course latter day saints havent claimed that the breathings of isis were the source of the book of abraham for to do so would be to admit defeatso can. Given this, some mormon apologists have postulated that the book of abraham manuscript was appended to the end of this scroll, and is no. Let him breathe together with that soul of his in 10 the afterlife with any form his heart desires together with the westerners. Both mormon and non mormon scholars agree the available fragments contain the book of breathings. If the book of mormon and the book of abraham are not true. The most common mormon response to this is to allege that the writings of abraham and joseph of egypt were contained in the papyri that are now lost. Mormons hoped the rediscovery and retranslation would validate the book of abraham and josephs ability to translate the book of mormon. They have translated the extant papyri and identified all of the remains as parts of the egyptian funerary texts, the book of the dead and the book of breathings. I have answered this question many times before on other venues but this question keeps being asked over and over because critics think its an open and shut case but it really isnt.
This was a reply to a common carrier article by jerald and sandra tanner, in the salt lake tribune november 11, 1973. The frequent occurrence of the word snsn provided a conspicuous clue, and, though the last page of the book the. Jun 20, 20 as one would expect, mormon intellectuals have sought to answer the criticisms of the book of abraham leveled in these and other works. A translation and commentary 2002 was published by the foundation for ancient research and mormon. Mormon apologists claim joseph smith channeled it so i guess that makes it ok. Michael marquardt a historian and author of over 45 articles and books on mormon historical topics who provides a history of the acquisition of the papyri, and translation by joseph smith and the subsequent publishing history of the book. The author of the ces letter fails to inform his readers that since the 1960s the church has freely admitted that the papyri fragments currently in possession of the church do not contain the book of abraham. The books of breathing are several late ancient egyptian funerary texts, intended to enable.
Dec 09, 2010 they have translated the extant papyri and identified all of the remains as parts of the egyptian funerary texts, the book of the dead and the book of breathings. In addition to ritner, several other authors contributed essays to the book. Investigating a remarkable mormon claim, and my evaluation of the basic flaws in the scholarship in that. Mormon scholar hugh nibley, who was appointed by the church of jesus christ of latterday saints to learn egyptian in order to defend the claim that joseph smith had found and translated a document from the hand of abraham, gives a short description of the book of breathings. Disproves lds claims that joseph smith received the book of abraham through revelation and proves that joseph smiths source for his translation was a pagan egyptian text, the book of breathings. Rhodes, and nonlds professor of egyptology robert k. Egyptian scholars have proven the writings of abraham are nowhere in the egyptian book of the dead or the book of breathings. Ritner, the joseph smith egyptian papyri a complete edition, pp.
These two books were connected by the man who said he was divinely gifted as a translator. The second volume in the farms series, the hor book of breathings is a complete publication of three of the remaining fragments of the joseph smith papyri. It is likely that it came at the end of the book of breathings text, of which facsimile 1. Book of abraham the standard works, or the mormon books of scripture, include the king james version of the bible, the book of mormon, the doctrine and covenants, and the pearl of great price. The king james quotations in the book of mormon, the history of the text of the book of mormon.
Mormon scholar hugh nibley, who was appointed by the church of jesus christ of latterday saints to learn egyptian in order to defend the claim. Other copies come from the ptolemaic and roman periods of egyptian history, as late as the second century ad. A translation and commentary, which was the second volume in the series entitled studies in the book of abraham by the foundation for ancient research and mormon studies farms at brigham young university. The joseph smith book of breathings opens with a vignette representing osiris on a lioncouch. The writing concerns itself with the afterlife of the egyptian priest hor. As one would expect, mormon intellectuals have sought to answer the criticisms of the book of abraham leveled in these and other works. For those who have devoutly believed in the book of mormon and the other lds scriptures, such as the book of abraham, as the word of god, coming to the realization that these books are not what they claim to be can cause ripple effects throughout their belief system. For the book of breathings is before all else, as bonnet observes, a. It must have been in much the same condition in joseph smiths day when fragments of it were glued haphazardly to other totally unrelated papyri. Lesko upon his retirement from the wilbour chair of egyptology at brown university june 2005 edited by stephen e. The lds church admits on their website that the book of abraham is not a translation of the papyri joseph claimed it was a translation of. Joseph smith had in his possession three or four long scrolls, plus a. Full text of book of breathings article by lanny bell.
A translation and commentary is volume two of the series studies in the book of abraham produced by the foundation for ancient research and mormon studies. In fact, part of the outer border of facsimile two in the book of abraham has some of these unrelated fragments inserted in it. These ancient hieroglyphics were part of a larger collection of scrolls, some of which were first translated as the book of abraham by the mormon prophet joseph smith in the mid1800s. It includes a complete publication of three of the remaining fragments of the joseph smith papyri. The book of breathings papyrus has no writing in red ink and is in an.
What is the book of breathings and book of the dead. The mormon church hoped the book of abraham would vindicate. The book of abraham opens with a vignette, in facsimile, representing abraham upon an altar. Printed together with thedoctrine and covenants of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints and the pearl of great price. They are considered inspired, with the book of mormon called equal. X and xi were quickly and easily identified as pages from the egyptian book of breathings. For this web site the spelling of hor or horus is for the same deceased person. The frequent occurrence of the word snsn provided a conspicuous clue, and, though the last page of the book the one that usually contains the title was missing.
What do mormons believe about the bible and the book of. Why does the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The book of mormon records the visit of jesus christ to people in the americas following his resurrection. Ritner both agree that missing characters in this line of the hor book of breathings are. The book of abraham papyri were thought to have been lost in the 1871 great chicago fire. The assumption in this attack is that the book of abraham was produced from only one scroll, and so if a facsimile was attached to the book of breathings, then the book of breathings must be the source of the rest of the book of abraham, not some missing text. Text accompanying the vignette at the end of the book of breathings text.
They actually were not, but the book of breathings was on the breast of a mummy. The book of mormon is a religious record of three groups of people who migrated from the old world to the american continents. Review of books on the book of mormon 19892011 volume 17number 2 article 14 2005 the book of breathings in its place kerry muhlestein follow this and additional works at. Posted on association for mormon letters discussion board. The ultimate purpose of the book of breathings was to provide the individual the secret knowledge necessary to be resurrected and deified in the presence of the gods. Official response of the mormon church to the book of abraham. November 26, 1977 by ben crowder abraham, book of abraham, book of breathings, gerald and sandra tanner, joseph smith papyri salt lake tribune sunday, november 25, 1973. Book of abrahamjoseph smith papyritext book of abraham. The mormon church hoped the book of abraham would vindicate joseph smith as a true prophet of god. The above donut chart shows percentages of the book of abraham section of letter to a ces director that fairmormon is in agreement, disagreement, and neutral on if one assumes that fairmormons undisputed silence is acceptance of the facts, fairmormon agrees with 90. Nonlds egyptologist analysis of the book of abraham papyri and facsimiles. Astronomy, papyrus, and covenant by gee and hauglid. They are now referred to as the joseph smith papyri. The computer program used to identify the first book of napoleon as being similar to the book of mormon compared it to over 5,000 books.
The book or document of breathings gradually took the place of the book of the dead in egyptian culture. Why doesnt the translation of the egyptian papyri found in. Js 1 and facsimile 3, that facsimiles 1 and 3 are similar in size,6 and that scenes similar to facsimile 3 also occur in other known copies of the first book of breathings. The book of mormon was said to have been translated from golden plates, which angels later took away, so the translation can no longer be checked against the originals. As a resu lt, the book of abraham has been the source of significant controversy. The format of this site may be changed periodically. Foundation for ancient research and mormon studies, brigham young university, 2002. Although the picture found as facsimile one in the book of abraham stands at the beginning of the book of breathings, this does not necessarily mean that it belongs to the text. A forum for exmormons and others who have been affected by mormonism to share news, commentary, and comedy about the mormon church.
The hor book of breathings is the second volume in the studies in the book of abraham series. One example of rhodes following coenens lead is in naming the hor book of breathings as a book of breathings made by isis. Debunking fairmormon letter to a ces director book of. Evidence for the divine authenticity of the book of abraham. Breathing permit of horus is created for persons who wish to understand this papyrus. May 30, 20 a short clip from the dvd a most remarkable book.
1401 412 158 1514 795 549 1149 1379 1366 1125 1368 46 1497 1094 963 465 1644 833 980 1380 655 504 677 558 586 515 1343 114 1602 825 1438 814 1528 1207 1080 1156 1145 519 993 1330 1396 915 1047 299 971 1016 30 265 194